...Tell the Difference Between a Scholarly and a Popular Periodical?

Characteristics   |   Appearance

Appearance
The previous page explained the difference between scholarly and popular periodicals. Now that you know the characteristics that make these types of publications different, you should be able to differentiate one from the other. Still not sure? Here are a few clues from the publications' appearance and content that may help you distinguish scholarly from popular. These clues aren't steadfast rules, though, and exceptions abound in both categories. If you are not sure whether a particular publication is scholarly or popular, ask your professor or a librarian.


The Cover:    Roll your mouse over the orange letters to view explanatory pop-up windows.
SCHOLARLY: POPULAR:
   
The Content:   Roll your mouse over the orange letters to view explanatory pop-up windows.
SCHOLARLY:

excerpted from Journal of Homosexuality, volume 45, numbers 2/3/4, 2003

 
POPULAR:

excerpted from The Advocate, July 22, 2003

Last updated February 13, 2004 by Elizabeth Putnam