Web Assignment #3, Who is Powerful and Why?

 

The purpose of this assignment is to explore the theoretical questions about interest group diversity, participation, and power. This assignment is designed to help you identify the powerful interest groups in your states, analyze why they are powerful, and how they are exercising that power.

  

 

Your presentation should cover 2 things

1.     the relative balance of power between parties, interest groups, and unions for the states in your region;

2.     a qualitative analysis of a single interest group in one of your states.

 

Which Interest Groups are powerful in your states?

To answer this question, go to the Follow the Money web site http://www.followthemoney.org, click on the EXPLORE on the top, and then STATE OVERVIEWS and click on your state (http://www.followthemoney.org/database/state_overview.phtml). Choose the year in which the most recent gubernatorial election was.  It is usually 2006 or 2008 (NJ, VA, MS are all in odd year elections).  You can tell by the dollar amount raised for gubernatorial election.  But make sure the data collection is complete. If they say, the data is only 35% complete, go to the previous gubernatorial election. Find the tables that identify the top 20 contributors and the top 15 industries. What do the state lists suggest about which interests are powerful? Who are the top individual contributors? Which are the dominant interests? Click on the Contributors tab below the State and Year line where it says

(Overview Candidates Contributors Ballot Measures Party Committees Data Sources)

 

Scroll down to Figure A which breaks down contributions by Sector and Figure B which shows contributions by Contributor type.

 

Using this data and charts, prepare a brief assessment (4 minutes) about which interest groups are powerful in your states? Your presentation should tell us who the big money interests are in your states and about the relative balance between public sector unions, parties, occupational/economic/business interests (realtors, utilities, banks, etc), lawyers/lobbyists, or ideological groups.

Who is the 600lb Gorilla in your states?

Look at the Top 20 Contributors to Candidates in your states and choose one group from one state that seems like it might be interesting. Prepare a 5 minute presentation on how that interest group is wielding power using the Thomas-Hrebenar model from (Who's Got Clout?  Interest Group Power in the States, Clive S. Thomas and Ronald J. Hrebenar, State Legislatures Magazine: April 1999 at http://www.ncsl.org/programs/pubs/499clout.htm. Your analysis should cover the following issues.

 

1.        What policy goal(s) is your interest group trying to achieve?

2.     What techniques or activities is your interest group engaging in to achieve their goals?  Why are they using these techniques and not others? (think about the insider/outsider dimension)

 

3.     What other groups, if any, are opposing them?  What techniques or activities are those interest group engaging in?

 

4.     Is your interest group playing partisan, majority, individual, or nonpartisan politics?  That is, are they aligned with one political party, one branch of government, or are they trying to win over both parties and all branches of government?  Is one institution or branch especially sympathetic?

 

5.     Why or why not were they successful were they in achieving their goals?

 

6.     What does the outcome suggest about the power of your interest group? Is it powerful, why or why not, and what are the limits on its power?

 

Where to find information to answer these questions:

1.     Look for state political blogs that follow the activities of these interests very closely.  If you do a google search for “Ohio politics”, you might be able to find the Buckeye politics blog.  (http://www.buckeyesenateblog.com/)  Governing Magazine also publishes a webpage with a list of state political blogs on the bottom left- http://governing.typepad.com/13thfloor/

2.     Look at the webpage of the interest group and see if they have a statement of their political activities. 

3. Do a Lexus Nexus search in the library. As far as search terms, the two best strategies I have found are to either use the proper name (Carolina Power and Light Employees PAC) or type in the organizations’ business and lobbying. For this example, I typed in “electric utility and lobbying” and returned 41 articles. If you have never used Lexus/Nexus, ask the reference librarian for assistance. It is a program that allows you to search a newspaper (like a state capital newspaper) using certain key words and pull up full text articles.