Argumentative Essay: Mini-paper #2
Oral arguing involves two or more persons taking opposing sides on a controversial issue. In written argumentation, this dialecticism is presented by one person: the writer. As the author of an argumentative essay, you are responsible for raising the arguments of the opposition. We call these opposing arguments "OBJECTIONS." An objection may oppose either the position or a specific argument and attempts to knock it out. Because the aims for argumentation are both inquiry and persuasion, you must present your objections fully and fairly. Your objections must also convey a clear understanding and appreciation of the point of view of the opposition. This understanding will be crucial when you offer rebuttals, the third component of an argumentative essay.

Mini-paper #2 will present objections to your position on the topic you have selected as the subject for paper #4.

Step One: PRE-WRITING

A. Make a list of at least five potential objections an opponent could raise against your position.
B. Consulting Mini-paper #1, make a list of at least two objections that an opponent could raise against one of your specific arguments.

Step Two (TO TURN IN):

In a brief, formal paper of approximately two pages, present the opposition's side to your topic and position. Your mini-paper should include the following parts exclusively:

A. BACKGROUND: In light of my comments on mini-paper #1, revise the background information on your topic, including adequate explanation on why this topic is important and/or controversial.
B. POSITION: At the conclusion of your first paragraph, present a revised, narrowly focused position statement on your topic. Remember, DO NOT change your position from the stance you chose for Mini-paper #1.
C. OBJECTIONS: Finally, present three or four fully supported objections that present an opponent's reasons for objecting to your position or to a specific argument. If they are objections to an argument, you may need to restate the argument briefly in a sentence before you give the objection.

Begin your second paragraph with the statement "In contrast, those opposed to this position argue that . . .

Mini-paper #2 will serve as an invaluable resource for writing your formal argumentative essay. It is ungraded; however, the three mini-papers combined account for 5% of the 25% weight of paper #4. I will comment on them to encourage you to develop your ideas as critically and fully as possible.

Click here for Questions to help you Analyze Paper Assignments

Click here for EN 103 Paper Assignment #4